Obsidian Insurance Review [Updated 2026]

A Deep Dive into the Hybrid Fronting Carrier Revolutionizing Program Business

By Gabriel Botelho 3 months ago

Co‑founder & CTO at Coverage Cat. Gabriel is obsessed with building products that improve user's insurance shopping experiences.

Obsidian Insurance Holdings emerged in 2020 with a clear mission: to build a better fronting carrier for managing general agents (MGAs) and program administrators in the specialty insurance market. While most consumers have never heard of this New York-based company, Obsidian plays a critical behind-the-scenes role in delivering homeowners insurance, auto insurance, umbrella insurance, and other coverage through specialized programs across the United States.

The company operates three distinct carriers—two admitted and one surplus lines—all rated A- (Excellent) by A.M. Best. With backing from private equity firm Genstar Capital and an experienced management team, Obsidian has posted impressive growth numbers. The company expects gross written premium to exceed $1 billion in 2025, marking its third consecutive year of over 50% premium growth (PR Newswire, "Obsidian Increases Surplus to Support Growth", 2025).

This review examines Obsidian's business model, financial strength, product offerings, and market position to help consumers understand the company behind many specialty insurance programs.

What Is Obsidian Insurance?

Obsidian Insurance Holdings operates as a hybrid fronting carrier, meaning it issues insurance policies underwritten by MGAs, managing general underwriters (MGUs), and program administrators, then cedes most of the risk to reinsurance partners (Obsidian Insurance Holdings, "About Us", 2026). The company was formed in 2020 through a partnership between insurance industry veterans and Genstar Capital, which contributed $100 million in initial capital (Genstar Capital, "Genstar Capital in Partnership with Management Announce Formation of Obsidian", 2020).

Rather than selling insurance directly to consumers, Obsidian provides the licensed carrier infrastructure that allows specialized underwriting organizations to bring products to market. The company maintains relationships with over 200 reinsurance partners to distribute risk across a diverse panel (Insurance Business America, "Obsidian boosts capital as it eyes further growth", 2025).

The holding company operates three licensed carriers:

  • Obsidian Insurance Company: An admitted carrier domiciled in Ohio
  • Obsidian Pacific Insurance Company: An admitted carrier acquired in 2021, formerly Western Home Insurance Company, domiciled in Minnesota and commercially domiciled in California
  • Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company: A surplus lines carrier domiciled in Delaware

All three carriers share the same A- (Excellent) financial strength rating from A.M. Best (Obsidian Insurance Holdings, "About Us", 2026).

What Kinds of Insurance Does Obsidian Offer?

Obsidian supports a diverse portfolio of property, casualty, and specialty insurance programs through its partner MGAs and program administrators. While the company does not sell policies directly to consumers, its carrier platforms enable programs across multiple lines of business.

According to A.M. Best's 2025 company report, general liability and auto insurance represent close to 70% of Obsidian's premium mix (A.M. Best Company, "BEST'S COMPANY REPORT - Obsidian Insurance Group", 2025). The company also supports programs in professional liability, property, and other specialty lines.

Recent partnerships and program launches demonstrate Obsidian's breadth:

The company targets risk retention of 5-10% on each program, with the balance ceded to reinsurance partners (A.M. Best Company, "BEST'S COMPANY REPORT - Obsidian Insurance Group", 2025).

Coverage Line Premium Share Key Characteristics
General Liability ~35% Commercial programs through MGA partners
Auto Insurance ~35% Hired/non-owned auto, commercial programs
Professional Liability Significant A&E, miscellaneous professional liability
Personal Umbrella Emerging Up to $5M limits, nationwide availability
Cyber Insurance Emerging Companies up to $1B revenue
Property Moderate E&S commercial property programs

Geographic Footprint and State Availability

Obsidian's three carriers provide countrywide coverage capabilities through a combination of admitted and surplus lines platforms. Financial data from the second quarter of 2024 shows the company's top five states by direct premium were Florida ($48.6 million), California ($31.7 million), Texas ($26.6 million), Washington ($9.2 million), and New Jersey ($8.5 million) (Florida Surplus Lines Service Office, "Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company Insurer Financial Report", 2024).

The acquisition of Western Home Insurance Company in 2021 specifically enhanced Obsidian's admitted carrier capabilities in California and five additional states (PR Newswire, "Obsidian Acquires Western Home Insurance Company", 2021). The surplus lines platform provides broader national reach for programs that require non-admitted capacity.

State regulatory records confirm Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company holds active licenses as a surplus lines carrier in multiple jurisdictions, including Missouri where it has maintained a clean compliance record since January 2021 (Missouri Department of Insurance, "Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company", 2026).

How Does Obsidian Work?

Unlike traditional insurance companies that market directly to consumers, Obsidian operates exclusively through partnerships with specialized underwriting organizations. The company describes itself as taking a "differentiated approach to program business" by working closely with reputable MGAs with whom management has established lasting business relationships (A.M. Best Company, "BEST'S COMPANY REPORT - Obsidian Insurance Group", 2025).

For consumers, this means Obsidian serves as the licensed carrier behind insurance programs marketed under different brand names. When you purchase coverage through an MGA or program administrator, you might find an Obsidian entity listed as the actual insurer on your policy documents, even though you applied through a different company.

The business model relies heavily on reinsurance to manage risk. Obsidian maintains relationships with 101 reinsurance partners, up from 45 when the company launched Ibid.. The company's top 10 reinsurers comprise 55% of ceded premium, and 52% of reinsurance recoverables come from parties rated A or higher by rating agencies. All reinsurance partners rated below A are fully collateralized Ibid..

This structure provides several advantages for the specialty programs Obsidian supports:

  • Regulatory compliance: Licensed carriers in multiple states
  • Financial strength: A- rating from A.M. Best provides confidence to consumers and regulators
  • Risk distribution: Reinsurance partnerships spread risk across numerous well-capitalized entities
  • Capital efficiency: Program managers can focus on underwriting rather than maintaining carrier infrastructure

For claims and customer service, policyholders typically interact with the MGA or program administrator that underwrote their coverage, though Obsidian provides oversight and maintains ultimate responsibility as the licensed carrier.

Leadership and Management Team

Obsidian's executive team brings deep insurance industry experience to the fronting carrier space. William Jewett serves as Chief Executive Officer with over 35 years of industry experience, including his previous role as President at Endurance Specialty (Genstar Capital, "Genstar Capital in Partnership with Management Announce Formation of Obsidian", 2020).

Craig Rappaport was promoted to President in July 2023 after serving as Chief Operating Officer and Chief Financial Officer since the company's founding. He brings more than 20 years of experience, including previous roles at Hanover Insurance Group (PR Newswire, "Obsidian Names Craig Rappaport President", 2023).

Other key executives include:

The board includes representation from Genstar Capital alongside industry veterans with experience at York Risk Services and Distinguished Programs Group (Genstar Capital, "Genstar Capital in Partnership with Management Announce Formation of Obsidian", 2020).

According to PitchBook data, the company employs 48 total staff members, reflecting its lean operational structure focused on program oversight rather than direct policy administration (PitchBook, "Obsidian Insurance Company 2026 Profile", 2026).

Financial Strength and Stability

Obsidian's financial profile reflects both its rapid growth and strong backing from private equity. The company maintains an A- (Excellent) financial strength rating from A.M. Best for all three of its carriers, with a stable outlook (A.M. Best Company, "AM Best Assigns Credit Ratings to Obsidian Insurance Company", 2020).

A.M. Best categorizes Obsidian's balance sheet strength as "very strong," supported by risk-adjusted capital well above required levels and a conservative investment portfolio dominated by high-quality fixed-income instruments (Ibid., "BEST'S COMPANY REPORT - Obsidian Insurance Group", 2025).

Kroll Bond Rating Agency (KBRA) provides additional perspective with its BBB- issuer rating for Obsidian Insurance Holdings and A- insurance financial strength ratings for the three operating carriers (KBRA, "KBRA Affirms Ratings for Obsidian Insurance Holdings and Subsidiaries", 2026). KBRA notes the company's hybrid fronting model and ownership by Genstar Capital with significant insurance experience. The rating agency affirmed these ratings with a stable outlook, recognizing experienced management, attractive market opportunities in fee-based business, and a conservative investment portfolio (KBRA, "KBRA Affirms Ratings for Obsidian Insurance Holdings and Insurance Subsidiaries", 2025).

Recent financial metrics demonstrate consistent growth:

The company raised $70 million in new capital in November 2025 through a combination of $40 million in senior unsecured notes (rated BBB- by KBRA) and $30 million in equity from existing shareholders including Genstar Capital Ibid.. The senior unsecured notes carry an 8% interest rate and mature on November 15, 2030 (Insurance Business America, "Obsidian boosts capital as it eyes further growth", 2025).

Reinsurance recoverables grew to $510 million in 2023 from $268 million in 2022, reflecting the company's expansion and reliance on its reinsurance panel to manage risk (A.M. Best Company, "BEST'S COMPANY REPORT - Obsidian Insurance Group", 2025).

Regulatory Standing and Compliance

State insurance department records show Obsidian maintains clean regulatory compliance across its operating jurisdictions. Missouri Department of Insurance records for Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company show active licensing status with no complaints on file, no market conduct examinations or investigations, and no enforcement actions in the past three years (Missouri Department of Insurance, "Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company", 2026).

The company holds federal authorization as an insurance filer with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, confirming regulatory compliance for commercial auto insurance programs (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, "OBSIDIAN SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANY", 2026).

Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company received its certificate of authority in Delaware in September 2020. The surplus lines carrier was capitalized with a $30 million cash contribution plus 100% of the capital stock of Obsidian Insurance Company (Insurance Journal, "Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company Receives A- Rating from AM Best", 2020). Ohio and Delaware Departments of Insurance approved consolidated group agreements for administrative services, tax sharing, and pooled reinsurance to facilitate the company's operational structure Ibid..

Pros and Cons

Pros

Strong Financial Ratings: All three carriers maintain A- (Excellent) ratings from A.M. Best, indicating excellent financial strength and ability to meet policyholder obligations (A.M. Best Company, "AM Best Assigns Credit Ratings to Obsidian Insurance Company", 2020).

Experienced Leadership: Management team brings decades of insurance industry experience from respected carriers and reinsurers (Genstar Capital, "Genstar Capital in Partnership with Management Announce Formation of Obsidian", 2020).

Rapid Growth: Three consecutive years of 50%+ premium growth demonstrates market confidence and strong demand for the company's fronting platform (PR Newswire, "Obsidian Increases Surplus to Support Growth", 2025).

Diverse Reinsurance Panel: Relationships with over 200 reinsurance partners provide robust risk distribution and reduce concentration risk (Insurance Business America, "Obsidian boosts capital as it eyes further growth", 2025).

Clean Regulatory Record: No complaints, enforcement actions, or market conduct issues in state insurance department records (Missouri Department of Insurance, "Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company", 2026).

Nationwide Coverage: Combined admitted and surplus lines platforms provide coast-to-coast capacity for specialty programs (Obsidian Insurance Holdings, "About Us", 2026).

Cons

Not Consumer-Facing: Obsidian does not sell insurance directly to consumers, making it difficult for policyholders to research or evaluate the company independently (Ibid., "About Us", 2026).

Limited Public Information: As a privately held company focused on B2B relationships, Obsidian provides minimal consumer-oriented information on its website or in public forums.

Young Company: Founded in 2020, Obsidian lacks the long operating history of established carriers, though management brings extensive industry experience (Genstar Capital, "Genstar Capital in Partnership with Management Announce Formation of Obsidian", 2020).

Reinsurance Dependency: Business model relies heavily on reinsurance partners, with reinsurance recoverables reaching $510 million in 2023 (A.M. Best Company, "BEST'S COMPANY REPORT - Obsidian Insurance Group", 2025).

Limited Direct Customer Support: Policyholders must typically work through MGAs or program administrators rather than contacting Obsidian directly for service needs.

Small Staff: With 48 total employees, the company maintains a lean organizational structure (PitchBook, "Obsidian Insurance Company 2026 Profile", 2026).

Ratings and Customer Feedback

Obsidian's B2B business model means traditional consumer review platforms contain limited information about the company. The table below summarizes available ratings from various sources:

Rating Source Rating Notes
A.M. Best A- (Excellent) Financial strength rating for all three carriers with stable outlook (A.M. Best Company, "AM Best Assigns Credit Ratings to Obsidian Insurance Company", 2020)
KBRA A- Insurance financial strength rating for operating carriers (KBRA, "KBRA Affirms Ratings for Obsidian Insurance Holdings and Subsidiaries", 2026)
KBRA (Holding Company) BBB- Issuer rating for Obsidian Insurance Holdings Ibid.
Better Business Bureau Not Rated Profile exists but not BBB accredited (BBB, "Obsidian Insurance Holdings, Inc.", 2026)
Trustpilot No Reviews No company profile found
Google Reviews No Reviews No public reviews of headquarters location
Missouri DOI Clean Record No complaints, examinations, or enforcement actions (Missouri Department of Insurance, "Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company", 2026)

The absence of consumer reviews reflects Obsidian's role as a fronting carrier rather than a direct-to-consumer insurer. Policyholders typically interact with the MGA or program administrator that underwrote their coverage, not with Obsidian directly.

Get Customer Support or File a Claim

Because Obsidian operates as a fronting carrier, policyholders typically contact the MGA or program administrator that issued their policy for customer service and claims support. The company's official website provides limited consumer-facing contact information:

For claims and policy servicing, check your insurance documents to identify the program administrator or MGA that manages your specific coverage. Contact information for your program manager should appear on your policy declarations page.

Federal motor carrier records list additional phone numbers: (800) 684-5428 and (732) 385-3257 (Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, "OBSIDIAN SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANY", 2026).

The company's headquarters are located at: 1330 Avenue of the Americas, Suite 23A New York, NY 10019 (Obsidian Insurance Holdings, "About Us", 2026)

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Obsidian Insurance Holdings, Inc. good insurance?

Yes. Obsidian Insurance Holdings operates three licensed insurance carriers rated A- (Excellent) by A.M. Best and A- by Kroll Bond Rating Agency (A.M. Best Company, "AM Best Assigns Credit Ratings to Obsidian Insurance Company", 2020), (KBRA, "KBRA Affirms Ratings for Obsidian Insurance Holdings and Subsidiaries", 2026). The company maintains clean regulatory standing and strong financial backing from Genstar Capital, which has invested $170 million total in the enterprise (PitchBook, "Obsidian Insurance Company 2026 Profile", 2026).

Who owns Obsidian Insurance?

Obsidian Insurance Holdings is a privately held company owned by Genstar Capital in partnership with management. Genstar contributed $100 million in initial capital when the company formed in 2020 (Genstar Capital, "Genstar Capital in Partnership with Management Announce Formation of Obsidian", 2020).

Can I buy insurance directly from Obsidian?

No. Obsidian operates as a fronting carrier that works exclusively with MGAs, MGUs, and program administrators. Consumers purchase coverage through these program managers, with Obsidian serving as the licensed carrier (Obsidian Insurance Holdings, "About Us", 2026).

What types of insurance does Obsidian provide?

Obsidian supports programs across property, casualty, and specialty lines. General liability and auto insurance represent close to 70% of premium, with additional programs in professional liability, umbrella insurance, cyber insurance, and other specialty coverages (A.M. Best Company, "BEST'S COMPANY REPORT - Obsidian Insurance Group", 2025).

How do I file a claim with Obsidian Insurance?

Contact the MGA or program administrator listed on your policy documents. They handle claims processing for policies written on Obsidian's carrier platforms. Your policy declarations page should include specific claims contact information.

Is Obsidian Insurance financially stable?

Yes. The company maintains A- (Excellent) financial strength ratings from A.M. Best with a stable outlook and very strong balance sheet strength Ibid.. Group capital and surplus reached $131.65 million in 2025 following a successful capital raise (PR Newswire, "Obsidian Increases Surplus to Support Growth", 2025).

What is a fronting carrier?

A fronting carrier provides the licensed insurance company infrastructure that allows MGAs and program administrators to issue policies. The fronting carrier typically retains a small percentage of risk (5-10% for Obsidian) and cedes the majority to reinsurance partners (A.M. Best Company, "BEST'S COMPANY REPORT - Obsidian Insurance Group", 2025).

In what states does Obsidian operate?

Obsidian's combined admitted and surplus lines platforms provide nationwide coverage. Top markets include Florida, California, Texas, Washington, and New Jersey (Florida Surplus Lines Service Office, "Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company Insurer Financial Report", 2024).

Has Obsidian had any regulatory issues?

State insurance department records show no complaints, market conduct examinations, investigations, or enforcement actions (Missouri Department of Insurance, "Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company", 2026).

How many reinsurance partners does Obsidian work with?

Obsidian maintains relationships with 101 reinsurance partners, up from 45 when the company launched in 2020 (A.M. Best Company, "BEST'S COMPANY REPORT - Obsidian Insurance Group", 2025). The company's programs are supported by a diverse panel of over 200 reinsurers, providing robust risk distribution (PR Newswire, "Obsidian Increases Surplus to Support Growth", 2025).

Market Position and Competitive Landscape

Obsidian operates in a competitive but consolidating fronting carrier market. CEO Bill Jewett predicted in 2023 that the number of fronting carriers could shrink by half within three to five years, with an estimated 30 carriers potentially condensing to 10-15 players due to consolidation pressures (Insurance Insider US, "Fronting consolidation could halve number of players in 3-5 years: Obsidian CEO", 2023). This outlook reflects the increasing market share of MGAs and the growing demand for fronting platforms that can efficiently connect risk with reinsurance and alternative capital.

The company launched with a clear vision to serve as a conduit between MGAs and reinsurance markets, including insurance-linked securities (ILS) funds (Artemis.bm, "Obsidian launches as fronting conduit to reinsurance & alternative capital", 2020). Hardening rates in the excess and surplus lines market and increased MGA activity drove the strategic decision to form Obsidian Specialty as a dedicated surplus lines platform (Insurance Journal, "Obsidian Specialty Insurance Company Receives A- Rating from AM Best", 2020).

The company's growth trajectory positions it well in this consolidating landscape. With expected gross written premium exceeding $1 billion in 2025 and continued investment in technology tools like the Program Analytical Review (PAR) data analytics platform introduced in 2022, Obsidian demonstrates both scale and operational sophistication (Obsidian Insurance Holdings, "Press", 2026).

Conclusion

Obsidian Insurance Holdings has established itself as a growing force in the specialty insurance fronting space since its 2020 founding. The company's A- ratings from A.M. Best and KBRA, experienced management team, strong financial backing from Genstar Capital, and clean regulatory record provide a solid foundation for continued growth.

For consumers, Obsidian remains largely invisible despite its role as the licensed carrier behind numerous specialty insurance programs. This B2B focus means policyholders typically interact with program administrators rather than Obsidian directly, though the company's financial strength and reinsurance relationships ultimately backstop many of these programs.

The company's rapid growth trajectory—with gross written premium expected to exceed $1 billion in 2025—demonstrates strong market demand for its hybrid fronting model (PR Newswire, "Obsidian Increases Surplus to Support Growth", 2025). Relationships with over 200 reinsurance partners provide risk distribution capabilities that benefit both program managers and policyholders.

If you find Obsidian listed as the carrier on your insurance policy, you can take confidence in the company's A- financial strength rating and clean regulatory record. For customer service and claims, work through the program administrator or MGA listed on your policy documents rather than contacting Obsidian directly.

Reviewed by Max Cho max.webp

Licensed Insurance Broker NPN 20377411

Max Cho is the founder and CEO of Coverage Cat and a licensed insurance broker (NPN 20377411). He builds consumer tools that make finding the best coverage simple for $1–10M households. Previously at Google, Two Sigma, and Microsoft, Max holds an M.A. in Computer Science (University of Washington) and a B.A. in Cognitive Science (Yale).
Methodology
Overview

In order to live up to our promise to our users of being the one-stop shop for their insurance needs Coverage Cat synthesizes information from across the web (and beyond!) to ensure our users have the best possible information so they can make informed insurance decisions. To enhance our first-party analysis of insurer-related data, we operate as a meta-critic for insurance marketplace participants and integrate information from other financial information sites like Nerdwallet, Bankrate, ValuePenguin, Wallethub, US News and World Report, Consumer Affairs, The Zebra, Clearsurance, MoneyGeek, CNBC, and others. Exceptions do exist however when high leverage data points present themselves in third party reviews or content. An example of this would be repeated customer criticisms of the same problem in reviews across platforms. When such exceptions exist they will be noted in-text.

Aggregate insurer statistics

In its function as the most consumer-obsessed source of information on insurers available online Coverage Cat serves a core function as a meta-aggregator of ratings from other sources, both governmental and private. We utilize the three types of aggregate statistics from third parties in our review process: 1) governmentally collected complaint statistics, 2) customer ratings collected by private companies, and 3) price estimates generated from aggregated data by third party insurance and financial ratings and review sites. 1) Aggregate complaint rates and scores, when pooled in places like the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) or by state insurance commissions, are simultaneously very informative— after all the effort for consumers to file these complaints is non-trivial— but can also mislead about the inherent "quality" of a given insurer. Our analysis of these published complaint rates finds that their volume and per-policy rate is often correlated with the socio-economic subset of the customers served by a given insurer. This indicates to us that some of the complaint rate is likely reflective of structural issues with poverty and the way in which financial products are sold as opposed to a direct reflection of the insurer's customer support quality. As such, we look for other sources like direct customer reviews to corroborate or contradict aggregate NAIC or state departments of insurance's high-level ratings. Generally, these account for about 15% of our final rating and evaluation for a given insurer. 2) While we do our best to integrate scores and reviews from third party websites like Trustpilot, BBB, Yelp, and Google Maps into our recommendation we are also cautious of adopting their aggregate scores wholesale as source of information. Some of these review websites allow companies that pay for subscriptions to their service to remove reviews that have been "responded to" or addressed by the company. This can often lead to a proliferation of positive reviews and aggregate scores that are not necessarily reflective of the way a carrier handles its clients. For the average Coverage Cat Review the reviews from third party sources account for about 15% of the weighted score we assign to a given insurance company or online insurance provider. 3) Coverage Cat Reviews will often report aggregate price estimates from other platforms and journalistic outlets in our reviews. These aggregated prices are often based on SERFF fillings, state insurance commissions aggregate data, and data collected by insurers and insurance aggregators. While these aggregated prices can sometimes help reveal general trends and price levels we've found that structural incentives and/or data availability often cause them to report averages that are innacurately low for the median consumer. As such we seek to only report them transparently so readers can have a sense of the overall price trends, but do not include them in our final insurer score.

User reviews

Customer voices weigh heavy in our methodology for insurance market participant reviews. User reviews are a crucial component of any balanced methodology in reviewing products and businesses online and it is no different with insurance. However, caveats similar to those provided for aggregate complaint ratings also apply to reviews (even those that are labeled as "verified") from 3rd party providers. Many of these review platform providers allow paying companies to hide or remove reviews that have been "resolved" or "answered" by companies. Even on platforms that do not allow for this type of shifting and obfuscation of negative reviews, like Reddit, companies are increasingly organize sophisticated marketing campaigns to shift perceptions of customer reviews. As such, we do our best to cross validate and flag reviews that seem innacurate based on a mosaic analysis with other signals related to a given company. Given these stipulations, user reviews account for approximately 70% of our Coverage Cat meta-critic score. In cases where only limited customer reviews are available online this number may fall to as low as 10% or we may decline to provide an overall Coverage Cat rating.

Financial ratings and reporting

Where available and relevant we will provide insurers' and Managing General Agents' (MGA) financial ratings from organizations such as Demotech, A.M. Best, and others. We do not speculate on the rated organizations' financial health nor do we have any data beyond these ratings and news reports on the financial health of these organizations. While we will contextualize the ratings for customers unfamiliar with them Coverage Cat is not a ratings agency and does not directly report or speculate on the financial health of insurance related companies.

In house expertise

Coverage Cat is a brokerage that deals with a significant number of insurers directly. Our agents also communicate with others brokers and professionals in the industry who work with their own sets of carriers. Our agents bring a wealth of expertise on topics including insurer pricing, accessibility, and marketing. As a result of this, we make use their seasoned judgement the production our reviews. Their opinions, experiences, community knowledge, and comparative expertise account for the last 10% of our insurance score.