Grange Insurance Review [Updated 2026]

Regional insurer with 90 years of history offers auto, home, and business insurance through independent agents

By Gabriel Botelho 3 months ago

Co‑founder & CTO at Coverage Cat. Gabriel is obsessed with building products that improve user's insurance shopping experiences.
  1. Introduction to Grange Insurance
  2. What Kinds of Insurance Does Grange Offer?
  3. Does Grange Sell Homeowners Insurance?
  4. Does Grange Sell Auto Insurance?
  5. Does Grange Sell Liability Insurance?
  6. How Does Grange Insurance Work?
  7. Pros and Cons of Grange Insurance
  8. Ratings and Customer Feedback for Grange Insurance
  9. Get Customer Support Or File A Claim For Grange Insurance
  10. Frequently Asked Questions

Introduction to Grange Insurance

Grange Insurance is a regional property and casualty insurer with nearly 90 years of experience serving customers across the Midwest and Southeast. The company formed on March 25, 1935, as Grange Mutual Holding Company, a non-profit corporation under Ohio law (Grange Insurance, "Legal", 2026). Based in Columbus, Ohio, the company operates in 13 states.

Through a network of approximately 3,600 independent agents, Grange offers auto, home, and business insurance protection to policyholders (Wikipedia, "Grange Insurance", 2026). The company has $3.4 billion in assets and generates more than $1.59 billion in annual revenue (Business Wire, "A.M. Best Reaffirms Grange Insurance's 'A' (Excellent) Rating and Stable Outlook", 2025).

It's important to note that Grange Insurance (Grange Mutual Holding Company) is separate from Grange Insurance Association, which operates in Western states. Grange Insurance is not affiliated with Grange Insurance Association, based in Seattle, or National Grange Insurance, based in Keene, N.H.

What Kinds of Insurance Does Grange Offer?

Grange Insurance provides a range of personal and commercial insurance products through independent agents. The company operates in Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia, and Wisconsin (Wikipedia, "Grange Insurance", 2026).

The company's personal insurance products include:

For business customers, Grange offers commercial property, commercial auto, business owners policies, and workers' compensation insurance.

Does Grange Sell Homeowners Insurance?

Yes, Grange sells homeowners insurance with both standard and optional coverages. Grange's homeowners insurance policies include standard coverages such as contents, dwelling, and liability.

The company offers several unique add-on options not commonly found with other insurers. Grange offers add-on options like assisted living care, which insures a family member's personal belongings if they live in an assisted living facility, and personal cyber insurance, which protects data, software and smart home systems if involved in a cyber attack.

Additional homeowners coverage options include:

  • Underground service line coverage
  • Equipment breakdown coverage
  • Sewer and drain backup protection
  • Identity theft coverage
  • Jewelry and valuables protection
Coverage Type Description Availability
Dwelling Standard protection for home structure All policies
Personal Property Contents coverage for belongings All policies
Liability Protection against lawsuits and claims All policies
Assisted Living Care Covers family member belongings in assisted living facilities Optional add-on
Personal Cyber Insurance Protects against cyber attacks on smart home systems Optional add-on
Underground Service Line Repairs to underground utilities Optional add-on

Homeowners Insurance Pricing

Grange Insurance's homeowners insurance rates are cheaper than the current national average of $2,304 per year for a policy with $300,000 in dwelling coverage, with Grange averaging $2,060 annually. However, Grange home insurance costs about $1,020 per year, which is around 16% more than average according to other industry analyses.

Homeowners Discounts

Grange offers a variety of home insurance discounts to help policyholders get the right protection at a price that fits their budget. Available discounts include:

  • Multi-policy discount for bundling home and auto
  • Home maintenance discount for proof of inspections
  • Advance quote discount for early renewal quotes
  • Home buyer discount for first-time buyers
  • DIY home inspection discount for virtual inspections through the mobile app

Does Grange Sell Auto Insurance?

Yes, Grange Insurance sells auto insurance with standard liability coverage and numerous optional add-ons. Grange's auto policies come with the required liability coverage, with the option to add collision, comprehensive, uninsured/underinsured motorist, medical payments, and more.

Unique Auto Coverage Options

Grange offers several distinctive coverage enhancements:

  • Pet injury coverage - Pays for veterinary bills if your pet is injured in a vehicle accident
  • Mobile device coverage - Protection for phones and tablets in your vehicle
  • Identity theft protection - Professional services and resources if your identity is stolen
  • Original equipment manufacturer (OEM) parts - Repairs use factory parts instead of aftermarket
  • Loan/lease gap coverage - Pays the difference between actual cash value and loan balance
  • Full glass coverage - Windshield and glass repair with no deductible
  • New car replacement - Replaces your vehicle with a new one after a total loss

Auto Insurance Pricing

Liability coverage from Grange Insurance costs an average of $83 per month, and full-coverage insurance costs an average of $172. A full coverage auto insurance policy from Grange averages $1,950 annually, below the national average of $2,458 per year.

However, Grange's minimum coverage policies tend to be a better deal than full coverage, as minimum policies cost about $44 per month (7% more than average) while full coverage costs about $136 per month (25% more expensive than average). (ConsumerAffairs, "Grange Insurance Reviews: Written By Customers", 2026) notes that customers report average monthly costs of approximately $178.79.

Auto Insurance Discounts

Grange offers a variety of discounts to help you save on car insurance, including:

  • Multi-policy discount
  • Multi-vehicle discount
  • Good student discount
  • Accidents and violation free discount
  • Student-away-at-school discount
  • Paperless billing discount
  • Accident forgiveness
  • Hybrid vehicle discount
  • New beginning discount (for newly separated or divorced drivers)

Does Grange Sell Liability Insurance?

Yes, Grange sells umbrella insurance policies that provide additional liability coverage beyond standard auto and home policies. A Grange umbrella policy covers claims beyond the limits of an existing auto or home insurance policy, adding additional liability coverage and may also cover claims that aren't covered by a standard liability policy, like slander, libel, and psychological harm.

How Does Grange Insurance Work?

Grange Insurance operates exclusively through independent insurance agents. Grange home insurance is sold exclusively through independent insurance agents. Insurance from Grange is only available through independent agents, meaning you can't simply go on the company's website to get a price like you can with many other insurers.

To purchase Grange insurance:

  1. Find a local agent - Visit Grange's website to locate an independent agent in your area
  2. Get a quote - Work with your agent to customize coverage based on your needs
  3. Review options - Discuss available discounts and optional coverages
  4. Bind coverage - Complete the application through your agent
  5. Manage your policy - Use the Grange Mobile app or online portal to pay bills, view coverage, and file claims

The Grange Mobile app allows customers to pay bills, view coverages, view ID cards, and get roadside assistance (Grange Insurance, "Grange Mobile App", 2025) (Apple App Store, "Grange Mobile", 2025).

Pros and Cons of Grange Insurance

Pros

Cons

  • Limited to 13 states in the Midwest and Southeast
  • Higher-than-expected complaint volume for home insurance based on NAIC data
  • No direct online quoting - must work through an agent
  • Not rated by J.D. Power for customer satisfaction studies
  • Home insurance rates may be higher than some competitors
  • Mobile app has mixed reviews regarding stability and functionality

Ratings and Customer Feedback for Grange Insurance

Financial Strength and Industry Ratings

Source Rating Details
AM Best A (Excellent) Reaffirmed in August 2025 with stable outlook; company included in AM Best's "Standing the Test of Time" list for 50+ years of top ratings
Better Business Bureau A+ BBB accredited since 1970 with strong rating and responsive complaint resolution
Issuer Credit Rating a+ (Excellent) Places Grange among top tier of U.S. insurance companies per AM Best
Innovation Rating Prominent Top 10% of companies reviewed by AM Best for innovation capabilities
Trustpilot 5.0 stars 111 reviews with 5 stars
U.S. News Reviewed Sells car insurance through independent agents with comprehensive coverage options

Customer Reviews Summary

On Trustpilot, Grange Mutual Insurance has a 4.5/5 rating, with customers highlighting timely responses and friendly staff, though some reviews mention concerns about policy renewal rates. (ConsumerAffairs, "Grange Insurance Reviews: Written By Customers", 2026) reports that customers praise personalized service and representative friendliness, with multiple customers noting claims settle quickly with responsive communication.

Real Customer Reviews

5 ★

Myra C., August 2025

via Trustpilot

As soon as we filed a claim, we had a representative on it. Mandy worked with us and pretty much "held our hand" as we walked through that horrible experience of loss. From the time we filed our claim until we were notified of getting our insurance payment to cover the loss was 12 days which is unheard of- plus we were dealing with a death in our immediate family at that same time. We are very thankful for the help from Mandy- I would highly recommend Grange!!

4 ★

/u/monroeins, 2014

via Reddit

My ex-wife recently had a claim with Grange. The car was totaled and they offered her a fair amount for her vehicle. After looking into it a little more we discovered something that made the car more valuable than everyone realized. I made a phone call and they promptly increased the payout by $800.

3 ★

/u/Excitingsetting, 2024

via Reddit

Grange's homeowners deductible is high, and they don't cover much unless it's a huge loss (your home burning down, for example).

2 ★

Mark H., Aug 2022

via Trustpilot

My car was involved in a minor accident, not at all my fault. The challenge came when I came to settle the final bill and the repair company insisted I pay the 'deductible' from my insurance. When I asked for this to be paid back by Grange, the problems started, with them procrastating, with various excuses, for months.

Get Customer Support Or File A Claim For Grange Insurance

Customer Service Contact Options

Grange Insurance offers 24/7 claims reporting and billing information, with technical website support available by phone at (800) 422-0550.

Phone: Contact customer service during business hours or 24/7 for claims Online: Submit inquiries through the contact form on Grange's website Mobile App: Access policy information, pay bills, and file claims through the Grange Mobile app Independent Agent: Contact your local Grange agent for policy questions and changes

How to File a Claim

Grange makes it easy to report and track insurance claims, with the ability to file, report or track claims across its auto, home, and business insurance products.

You can file a claim through:

  • Phone: Call 24/7 claims hotline to report a claim - (800) 445-3030 or if you already have one active use their tracking number (800) 686-0025
  • Mobile App: Report claims directly through the Grange Mobile app
  • Online: Submit claims through the MyGrange online portal or their claims site
  • Independent Agent: Contact your local agent for claim assistance

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Grange Insurance a Real Insurance Company?

Yes. Grange Insurance is a legitimate company with a history of more than 80 years, with a mix of positive and negative reviews but not linked to any fraudulent practices.

Should I Buy Grange Insurance?

Grange Insurance is a reasonably good insurance company for those who live in the 13 states where it's available, standing out for its policy customization and flexibility, with wide selection of coverage options. The company may be a good fit if you value:

  • Working with a local independent agent
  • Customizable coverage options with unique add-ons
  • Strong financial ratings and long company history
  • Below-average rates for auto insurance full coverage

However, Grange may not be ideal if you need nationwide availability or prefer direct online quoting.

How Does Grange Insurance Make Money?

Grange Insurance generates revenue by collecting premiums from policyholders and investing those premium reserves. As a mutual company, Grange is owned by its policyholders rather than shareholders.

Is Grange Insurance Worth It?

Grange Insurance is a good car insurance option thanks to its numerous discounts and multiple great coverages, with a reputation for providing good customer service and a high Better Business Bureau rating. However, despite the many discounts offered, Grange is still more expensive than many of its competitors, so comparison shopping is recommended.

Can I Get a Quote Online?

No. You can't simply go on the company's website to get a price like you can with many other insurers. You'll have to pick up the phone or visit an insurance agency to get a quote.

How Do I Cancel My Grange Insurance Policy?

To cancel Grange insurance, the policyholder must contact their independent agent. The cancellation can be arranged for a future date or set to take effect immediately. You will need your name, policy number, and the date you want your policy to end. If you've already paid your premium for the policy period in full, Grange will refund the unused portion, minus any cancellation fees.

Reviewed by Max Cho max.webp

Licensed Insurance Broker NPN 20377411

Max Cho is the founder and CEO of Coverage Cat and a licensed insurance broker (NPN 20377411). He builds consumer tools that make finding the best coverage simple for $1–10M households. Previously at Google, Two Sigma, and Microsoft, Max holds an M.A. in Computer Science (University of Washington) and a B.A. in Cognitive Science (Yale).
Methodology
Overview

In order to live up to our promise to our users of being the one-stop shop for their insurance needs Coverage Cat synthesizes information from across the web (and beyond!) to ensure our users have the best possible information so they can make informed insurance decisions. To enhance our first-party analysis of insurer-related data, we operate as a meta-critic for insurance marketplace participants and integrate information from other financial information sites like Nerdwallet, Bankrate, ValuePenguin, Wallethub, US News and World Report, Consumer Affairs, The Zebra, Clearsurance, MoneyGeek, CNBC, and others. Exceptions do exist however when high leverage data points present themselves in third party reviews or content. An example of this would be repeated customer criticisms of the same problem in reviews across platforms. When such exceptions exist they will be noted in-text.

Aggregate insurer statistics

In its function as the most consumer-obsessed source of information on insurers available online Coverage Cat serves a core function as a meta-aggregator of ratings from other sources, both governmental and private. We utilize the three types of aggregate statistics from third parties in our review process: 1) governmentally collected complaint statistics, 2) customer ratings collected by private companies, and 3) price estimates generated from aggregated data by third party insurance and financial ratings and review sites. 1) Aggregate complaint rates and scores, when pooled in places like the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) or by state insurance commissions, are simultaneously very informative— after all the effort for consumers to file these complaints is non-trivial— but can also mislead about the inherent "quality" of a given insurer. Our analysis of these published complaint rates finds that their volume and per-policy rate is often correlated with the socio-economic subset of the customers served by a given insurer. This indicates to us that some of the complaint rate is likely reflective of structural issues with poverty and the way in which financial products are sold as opposed to a direct reflection of the insurer's customer support quality. As such, we look for other sources like direct customer reviews to corroborate or contradict aggregate NAIC or state departments of insurance's high-level ratings. Generally, these account for about 15% of our final rating and evaluation for a given insurer. 2) While we do our best to integrate scores and reviews from third party websites like Trustpilot, BBB, Yelp, and Google Maps into our recommendation we are also cautious of adopting their aggregate scores wholesale as source of information. Some of these review websites allow companies that pay for subscriptions to their service to remove reviews that have been "responded to" or addressed by the company. This can often lead to a proliferation of positive reviews and aggregate scores that are not necessarily reflective of the way a carrier handles its clients. For the average Coverage Cat Review the reviews from third party sources account for about 15% of the weighted score we assign to a given insurance company or online insurance provider. 3) Coverage Cat Reviews will often report aggregate price estimates from other platforms and journalistic outlets in our reviews. These aggregated prices are often based on SERFF fillings, state insurance commissions aggregate data, and data collected by insurers and insurance aggregators. While these aggregated prices can sometimes help reveal general trends and price levels we've found that structural incentives and/or data availability often cause them to report averages that are innacurately low for the median consumer. As such we seek to only report them transparently so readers can have a sense of the overall price trends, but do not include them in our final insurer score.

User reviews

Customer voices weigh heavy in our methodology for insurance market participant reviews. User reviews are a crucial component of any balanced methodology in reviewing products and businesses online and it is no different with insurance. However, caveats similar to those provided for aggregate complaint ratings also apply to reviews (even those that are labeled as "verified") from 3rd party providers. Many of these review platform providers allow paying companies to hide or remove reviews that have been "resolved" or "answered" by companies. Even on platforms that do not allow for this type of shifting and obfuscation of negative reviews, like Reddit, companies are increasingly organize sophisticated marketing campaigns to shift perceptions of customer reviews. As such, we do our best to cross validate and flag reviews that seem innacurate based on a mosaic analysis with other signals related to a given company. Given these stipulations, user reviews account for approximately 70% of our Coverage Cat meta-critic score. In cases where only limited customer reviews are available online this number may fall to as low as 10% or we may decline to provide an overall Coverage Cat rating.

Financial ratings and reporting

Where available and relevant we will provide insurers' and Managing General Agents' (MGA) financial ratings from organizations such as Demotech, A.M. Best, and others. We do not speculate on the rated organizations' financial health nor do we have any data beyond these ratings and news reports on the financial health of these organizations. While we will contextualize the ratings for customers unfamiliar with them Coverage Cat is not a ratings agency and does not directly report or speculate on the financial health of insurance related companies.

In house expertise

Coverage Cat is a brokerage that deals with a significant number of insurers directly. Our agents also communicate with others brokers and professionals in the industry who work with their own sets of carriers. Our agents bring a wealth of expertise on topics including insurer pricing, accessibility, and marketing. As a result of this, we make use their seasoned judgement the production our reviews. Their opinions, experiences, community knowledge, and comparative expertise account for the last 10% of our insurance score.