Elephant Insurance Review [Updated 2026]

Should you try Elephant Auto Insurance?

By Jazzmin Lu 3 months ago

Jazzmin is a licensed insurance broker, NPN 1842252. Jazzmin likes dogs, cats, growth, and great content! She holds a B.A. from Yale University and a Marketing Masters from the University of Colorado-Denver with a focus on Marketing Strategy and Consumer Behavior.
  1. Introduction to Elephant Insurance
  2. What Kinds of Insurance Does Elephant Offer?
  3. How Does Elephant Insurance Work?
  4. Pros and Cons of Elephant Insurance
  5. Ratings and Customer Feedback for Elephant Insurance
  6. Get Customer Support Or File A Claim For Elephant Insurance
  7. Frequently Asked Questions

Introduction to Elephant Insurance

Elephant Insurance Company (Elephant) was founded in 2009 as a subsidiary of The Admiral Group plc, a FTSE 100 insurance company based in the U.K. On January 1, 2026, Admiral Group completed the sale of Elephant to J.C. Flowers & Co., a global private equity firm focused on financial services. Elephant provides auto insurance in Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia. It operates primarily as a direct-to-consumer company and gives a discount to consumers who buy policies online. Consumers who prefer to buy through an agent may call Elephant or work with one of its licensed brokers.

According to FinTech Wales, Elephant served approximately 140,000 customers by the end of 2024 and turned around from a £19.6 million loss in 2023 to a £14 million profit in 2024. The company maintains a 90% customer retention rate at renewal, which means most policyholders choose to stay with Elephant when their policies come up for renewal.

Elephant claims to make it easier to understand insurance and coverage through products such as their Coverage Wizard, a tool that identifies customer insurance needs through just a few questions. Elephant also offers discounts if a client has a good driving record, works from home, or insures multiple cars.

What Kinds of Insurance Does Elephant Offer?

Elephant sells personal auto insurance as its primary product. Elephant insurance agents may also offer quotes for other products through insurance partnerships including Dairyland motorcycle insurance; Lemonade homeowners, condo, and renters insurance; RLI for personal liability insurance; and recreational vehicle and watercraft insurance.

Elephant auto coverage can include bodily injury, property damage, comprehensive and collision, medical payments, and underinsured/uninsured motorists, although not all coverage is available in all states. According to U.S. News & World Report, less common coverage options include pet injury coverage up to $1,000 in vet bills and custom equipment coverage for customized vehicles. Add-on coverage options include real time road assistance, rental reimbursement, parts and equipment coverage, claim forgiveness, and diminishing deductibles. According to Elephant's blog, roadside assistance costs $3–$5 per month.

Coverage Type Availability Add-On Cost (Annual)
Liability (Bodily Injury & Property Damage) All states Standard
Comprehensive & Collision All states Varies by vehicle
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist All states Standard
Medical Payments All states Standard
Roadside Assistance All states ~$35
Rental Reimbursement All states ~$35
Pet Injury Coverage Select states Included (up to $1,000)
Custom Equipment Coverage Select states Varies
Claim Forgiveness Select states Varies

Does Elephant Sell Auto Insurance?

Yes, Elephant Insurance sells auto insurance. It is their primary product and is offered in Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia. Elephant offers auto quotes directly through their website or through licensed brokers, such as Coverage Cat.

Does Elephant Sell Homeowners Insurance?

Yes, Elephant sells homeowners, condo, and renters insurance through a partnership with Lemonade. These policies are underwritten by Lemonade, not Elephant directly.

Does Elephant Sell Liability Insurance?

Yes, Elephant sells liability insurance. Elephant's auto insurance policies include bodily injury liability and property damage liability, and their homeowners, condo, and renters policies through Lemonade can also offer limited personal liability coverage.

Elephant also offers umbrella insurance, or excess personal liability insurance for high net worth individuals through a partnership with RLI. These quotes, however, are only available by calling an Elephant agent and may require purchasing an Elephant auto policy. High net worth individuals, policyholders who have inexperienced drivers on their insurance, people who frequently host parties, or individuals at high risk of lawsuits may decide to purchase umbrella insurance as coverage typically starts at $1 million.

How Does Elephant Insurance Work?

To purchase Elephant Insurance directly, customers can create an online quote or call 1-877-321-2096 to speak with an insurance agent. Elephant policies are also sold through licensed brokers, such as Coverage Cat.

Filing a claim and requesting roadside assistance can be done online or from the Elephant Insurance mobile app. According to the company's claims page, claims can be filed 24/7 using their online claims tool, while phone claims are available Monday-Friday 8:00AM-7:00PM ET for new claims and Monday-Friday 8:00AM-5:00PM ET for existing claims support.

Pros and Cons of Elephant Insurance

Pros

  • Elephant offers a mobile app for policyholders that allows them to view ID cards offline, manage billing and payments, make policy changes, and file claims.
  • Elephant offers an "Elephant Approved Repair Service" perk for free, giving customers access to pre-qualified repair shops nationwide.
  • Elephant offers multiple discounts, including work from home discounts that take into account how many days customers work from home.
  • Trustpilot rates Elephant "Excellent" with 4.5 out of 5 stars based on over 1,200 customer reviews, and customers praise competitive pricing and an easy online quote process.
  • The company was recognized on USA TODAY's America's Best Customer Service in Financial Services 2026 list, which evaluated 31,000 customers across 2,500 providers.

Cons

  • Elephant's geographic coverage is limited and is currently available only in Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia.
  • Elephant agents are not available 24/7 for phone support, though online claims filing is available around the clock.
  • According to Miller & Zois, personal injury attorneys note that Elephant uses outside counsel for litigation rather than a large in-house legal team, and the company receives more complaints filed with state regulators than the average insurer of its size.

Ratings and Customer Feedback for Elephant Insurance

Elephant Insurance reviews and Elephant insurance ratings come from multiple sources. The Better Business Bureau gives Elephant an A+ rating, though the BBB profile documents recent complaints involving claims processing disputes and billing issues. Admiral Group, Elephant's former parent company, holds an A+ rating from AM Best, which applies to Admiral and not to Elephant directly (AM Best, "Admiral Group A+ Rating", 2024).

Rating Source Score Notes
Trustpilot 4.5/5 stars Over 1,200 reviews; rated "Excellent"
Better Business Bureau A+ Recent complaints about claims and billing
NAIC Complaint Index (Private Passenger Auto) 0.94 Better than expected (1.00 is average)
Customer Retention Rate 90% High renewal rate from October-December 2024
USA TODAY Customer Service Award 2026 America's Best Customer Service in Financial Services

Trustpilot reviewers highlight competitive pricing and a straightforward online quote process as major positives. Some customers complain about billing problems and rate increases at renewal. The company responds to complaints on the BBB platform with explanations and contact information.

Elephant earned Great Place to Work Certification consecutively from 2017-2025 and has been named a Richmond Top Workplace for most years between 2010 and 2025. These workplace awards suggest internal company culture supports employee satisfaction, which can translate to better customer service.

Get Customer Support Or File A Claim For Elephant Insurance

Elephant Insurance offers customer support through multiple channels. Policyholders can file claims 24/7 through the online claims portal or the Elephant Insurance mobile app. For phone support, new claims can be filed Monday-Friday 8:00AM-7:00PM ET, and existing claims support is available Monday-Friday 8:00AM-5:00PM ET.

The mobile app allows policyholders to view ID cards offline, manage billing and payments, make policy changes, and file claims. Elephant also provides access to its Elephant Approved Repair Service program, which connects customers with pre-qualified repair shops nationwide at no additional cost.

For general inquiries, customers can call 1-877-321-2096 or visit the contact page on Elephant's website.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I Buy Elephant Insurance?

If you live in Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Tennessee, Texas, or Virginia, Elephant Insurance could be a good option. However, it's best to compare quotes from other insurers to decide if Elephant is best for you. According to U.S. News & World Report, Elephant insurance discounts can save up to 40% on premiums, which makes comparison shopping worthwhile.

To get a variety of insurance quotes from different carriers, including smaller carriers like Elephant, you can work with a licensed insurance broker like Coverage Cat.

Is Elephant Insurance a Real Insurance Company?

Yes, Elephant is a real insurance company. Founded in 2009, it was a part of Admiral Group, a FTSE 100 company and one of the leading insurers in the United Kingdom. As of January 1, 2026, Elephant is now owned by J.C. Flowers & Co., a global private equity firm dedicated to financial services.

How Does Elephant Make Money?

Elephant makes money by collecting the premiums paid by its policyholders, investing the cash from the premiums, and trying to lower expenses such as claims and operating costs. FinTech Wales reports that Elephant turned around from a £19.6 million loss in 2023 to a £14 million profit in 2024, showing improved financial performance.

Is Elephant Insurance Worth the Price?

The only way to know for sure whether Elephant is right for you is to compare its quote and coverage options with other insurers'. Customer retention data shows that 90% of Elephant customers renew their policies, which suggests many policyholders find value in staying with the company.

Coverage Cat can help you find the best possible offers and make it easy to buy the best possible policy.

What Are Common Elephant Insurance Complaints?

Common Elephant insurance complaints involve billing issues, rate increases at renewal, and claims processing disputes. Miller & Zois notes that Elephant receives more complaints filed with state regulators than the average insurer of its size. However, the company's NAIC complaint index for private passenger auto insurance (0.94) is better than the national expected average, and Trustpilot reviews remain largely positive overall.

Is Elephant Good Insurance for High-Risk Drivers?

Elephant Insurance focuses on direct-to-consumer auto insurance for standard and preferred risk drivers. The company does not specifically market to high-risk drivers. If you have a poor driving record, multiple accidents, or DUI convictions, you may want to compare quotes from carriers that specialize in non-standard auto insurance alongside your Elephant quote.

Reviewed by Max Cho max.webp

Licensed Insurance Broker NPN 20377411

Max Cho is the founder and CEO of Coverage Cat and a licensed insurance broker (NPN 20377411). He builds consumer tools that make finding the best coverage simple for $1–10M households. Previously at Google, Two Sigma, and Microsoft, Max holds an M.A. in Computer Science (University of Washington) and a B.A. in Cognitive Science (Yale).
Methodology
Overview

In order to live up to our promise to our users of being the one-stop shop for their insurance needs Coverage Cat synthesizes information from across the web (and beyond!) to ensure our users have the best possible information so they can make informed insurance decisions. To enhance our first-party analysis of insurer-related data, we operate as a meta-critic for insurance marketplace participants and integrate information from other financial information sites like Nerdwallet, Bankrate, ValuePenguin, Wallethub, US News and World Report, Consumer Affairs, The Zebra, Clearsurance, MoneyGeek, CNBC, and others. Exceptions do exist however when high leverage data points present themselves in third party reviews or content. An example of this would be repeated customer criticisms of the same problem in reviews across platforms. When such exceptions exist they will be noted in-text.

Aggregate insurer statistics

In its function as the most consumer-obsessed source of information on insurers available online Coverage Cat serves a core function as a meta-aggregator of ratings from other sources, both governmental and private. We utilize the three types of aggregate statistics from third parties in our review process: 1) governmentally collected complaint statistics, 2) customer ratings collected by private companies, and 3) price estimates generated from aggregated data by third party insurance and financial ratings and review sites. 1) Aggregate complaint rates and scores, when pooled in places like the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) or by state insurance commissions, are simultaneously very informative— after all the effort for consumers to file these complaints is non-trivial— but can also mislead about the inherent "quality" of a given insurer. Our analysis of these published complaint rates finds that their volume and per-policy rate is often correlated with the socio-economic subset of the customers served by a given insurer. This indicates to us that some of the complaint rate is likely reflective of structural issues with poverty and the way in which financial products are sold as opposed to a direct reflection of the insurer's customer support quality. As such, we look for other sources like direct customer reviews to corroborate or contradict aggregate NAIC or state departments of insurance's high-level ratings. Generally, these account for about 15% of our final rating and evaluation for a given insurer. 2) While we do our best to integrate scores and reviews from third party websites like Trustpilot, BBB, Yelp, and Google Maps into our recommendation we are also cautious of adopting their aggregate scores wholesale as source of information. Some of these review websites allow companies that pay for subscriptions to their service to remove reviews that have been "responded to" or addressed by the company. This can often lead to a proliferation of positive reviews and aggregate scores that are not necessarily reflective of the way a carrier handles its clients. For the average Coverage Cat Review the reviews from third party sources account for about 15% of the weighted score we assign to a given insurance company or online insurance provider. 3) Coverage Cat Reviews will often report aggregate price estimates from other platforms and journalistic outlets in our reviews. These aggregated prices are often based on SERFF fillings, state insurance commissions aggregate data, and data collected by insurers and insurance aggregators. While these aggregated prices can sometimes help reveal general trends and price levels we've found that structural incentives and/or data availability often cause them to report averages that are innacurately low for the median consumer. As such we seek to only report them transparently so readers can have a sense of the overall price trends, but do not include them in our final insurer score.

User reviews

Customer voices weigh heavy in our methodology for insurance market participant reviews. User reviews are a crucial component of any balanced methodology in reviewing products and businesses online and it is no different with insurance. However, caveats similar to those provided for aggregate complaint ratings also apply to reviews (even those that are labeled as "verified") from 3rd party providers. Many of these review platform providers allow paying companies to hide or remove reviews that have been "resolved" or "answered" by companies. Even on platforms that do not allow for this type of shifting and obfuscation of negative reviews, like Reddit, companies are increasingly organize sophisticated marketing campaigns to shift perceptions of customer reviews. As such, we do our best to cross validate and flag reviews that seem innacurate based on a mosaic analysis with other signals related to a given company. Given these stipulations, user reviews account for approximately 70% of our Coverage Cat meta-critic score. In cases where only limited customer reviews are available online this number may fall to as low as 10% or we may decline to provide an overall Coverage Cat rating.

Financial ratings and reporting

Where available and relevant we will provide insurers' and Managing General Agents' (MGA) financial ratings from organizations such as Demotech, A.M. Best, and others. We do not speculate on the rated organizations' financial health nor do we have any data beyond these ratings and news reports on the financial health of these organizations. While we will contextualize the ratings for customers unfamiliar with them Coverage Cat is not a ratings agency and does not directly report or speculate on the financial health of insurance related companies.

In house expertise

Coverage Cat is a brokerage that deals with a significant number of insurers directly. Our agents also communicate with others brokers and professionals in the industry who work with their own sets of carriers. Our agents bring a wealth of expertise on topics including insurer pricing, accessibility, and marketing. As a result of this, we make use their seasoned judgement the production our reviews. Their opinions, experiences, community knowledge, and comparative expertise account for the last 10% of our insurance score.